BBC Horizon’s “E-Cigarettes: Miracle or Menace?” – Truth or Treachery?

Monday, 23 May 2016

Last Sunday’s Horizon on BBC Two focused on e-cigarettes, so it's time to check out if this episode got its facts right amid the lies and stigma surrounding vaping. 

During the programme, presenter Michael Mosley took up vaping for a month having never smoked a day in his life. This isn’t advisable, but then again the man has already swallowed a tapeworm and done the 5:2 diet, so we’re not going to judge him.

Mosley talked to the experts about vaping and the results were surprising. Most experts he spoke to agreed that e-cigarettes were much less harmful than conventional cigarettes, and even he wasn’t concerned by the short term effects of vaping. 

Nicotine Addiction?

His biggest concern was becoming addicted to nicotine, however this turned out to not happen. He instead found that having to puff on the e-cigarette so regularly soon became a chore to him. What’s more, his children were unimpressed and had no intention of copying him, thinking that it wasn’t cool.

In fact, new research seemed to indicate that nicotine alone is not as addictive as we once thought, and it is potentially the combination of nicotine and other chemicals present in cigarettes that causes the addiction.

Vaping on the Horizon

Nicotine can even have its benefits in some cases – a study in the US has recently been funded to explore the potential benefits of nicotine on patients with mild cognitive impairment (an Alzheimer’s precursor). They’ll be given regular nicotine patches or a placebo patch and will receive health checks and cognition tests to see if nicotine can help their memory.

What About Smokers?

The programme also followed regular smokers as they tried to kick the habit. The smokers tried a range of techniques designed to help quit smoking – chewing nicotine gum, wearing nicotine patches – as well as e-cigarettes and even trying to go cold turkey.

The results clearly showed that e-cigarettes do have a part to play in helping people quit smoking, even if manufacturers and retailers can’t fully say it yet due to the obvious regulation around smoking cessation equipment. During the study, e-cigarettes were much more effective in helping people to quit smoking than going cold turkey.

So It’s Totally Safe?

Well, not entirely. The show also covered the other side of the equation. At the end of his month of heavy vaping, Mosley showed signs of increased inflammation in his lungs. While this rapidly reversed when he stopped vaping, it does show that vaping isn’t without its risks.

Even with the potential risks, Mosley came out fully in support of vaping as a smoking alternative, both for the health benefits and its potential use as a smoking cessation tool.

See Our Trending E-Liquids!

DOT Strawberry Refill Pods

DOT Strawberry Refill Pods

£5.99
Available
  • Delicate, sweet strawberry flavour
  • Strength: 20mg
  • VG: 50%, PG: 50%
  • Made in the United Kingdom
Element Dripper Pink Grapefruit E-Liquid - Money Off!

Element Dripper Pink Grapefruit E-Liquid - Money Off!

£2.39
(RRP: £3.99)
Available
  • Pink grapefruit flavour
  • Strengths: 0mg, 3mg, 6mg
  • VG: 80%, PG: 20%
  • Made in the USA
Iceliqs Originals Vanilla Surprise E-Liquid

Iceliqs Originals Vanilla Surprise E-Liquid

£3.99
Available
  • Pure vanilla flavour
  • Available in 0mg, 6mg, 11mg and 16mg strengths
  • VG: 30%, PG: 70%
  • Made in France
Eco Vape Dripping Vampire Astaire Max VG E-Juice

Eco Vape Dripping Vampire Astaire Max VG E-Juice

£6.99
Available
  • Blackberry and black grape flavour with eucalyptus and aniseed
  • Available with a 3mg or 6mg nicotine strength
  • VG: 80%, PG: 20%
  • Made in the United Kingdom
Beard Vape Co X Series No. 51 Short Fill E-Liquid

Beard Vape Co X Series No. 51 Short Fill E-Liquid

£14.99
Available
  • Vanilla custard flavoured
  • Strength: 0mg (PlusNic-ready)
  • VG: 85%, PG: 15%
  • Made in the USA
Kilo White Series Cinnamon Rolls E-Liquid - Money Off!

Kilo White Series Cinnamon Rolls E-Liquid - Money Off!

£1.60
(RRP: £3.99)
Available
  • Freshly-baked cinnamon rolls
  • Strengths: 0mg, 3mg, 6mg
  • VG: 70%, PG: 30%
  • Made in the USA
Nicocig Refill Cartridges Medium Strength Tobacco Cartomisers

Nicocig Refill Cartridges Medium Strength Tobacco Cartomisers

£4.75
Available
  • Refill cartomisers for Nicocig and Nicolites Rechargeable Electronic Cigarettes
  • Tobacco flavoured cartridges with medium nicotine strength
  • Available in packs of 5, 10, 20, 30 and 40 boxes
  • Also compatible with Nicolites electronic cigarettes
Logic Pro E-Cigarette Tobacco 18mg Combination Pack

Logic Pro E-Cigarette Tobacco 18mg Combination Pack

£32.99
Available
  • Stainless steel construction
  • Capsule design allows easier refilling
  • Long-lasting battery charges in 3 hours
  • Includes 18 x Tobacco 18mg Refill Capsules
Liberty Flights XO Super Highway E-Liquid - Money Off!

Liberty Flights XO Super Highway E-Liquid - Money Off!

£2.50
(RRP: £4.99)
Available
  • Strong tobacco flavour - just like real cigarettes
  • Available in 0mg, 3mg, 6mg, 12mg and 18mg nicotine strengths
  • VG: 50%, PG: 50%
  • Made in the United Kingdom
Element Mojito E-Liquid

Element Mojito E-Liquid

£3.99
Available
  • Mojito flavoured
  • Strengths: 0mg, 6mg, 12mg, 18mg
  • VG: 50%, PG: 50%
  • Made in the USA
Eco Vape Psycho Bunny Well Baked E-Liquid

Eco Vape Psycho Bunny Well Baked E-Liquid

£6.99
Available
  • Cherry bakewell flavoured E-liquid
  • Strength: 3mg, 6mg
  • VG: 80%, PG: 20%
  • Made in the UK
Iceliqs Originals USA Original E-Liquid

Iceliqs Originals USA Original E-Liquid

£3.99
Available
  • Classic American tobacco flavour
  • Available in 0mg, 6mg, 11mg and 16mg strengths
  • VG: 30%, PG: 70%
  • Made in France